Avey gets to play the prophet-without-honour, martyr while the treatment of Coward shows this is pretty false. Common factors are always ythe vaguest ones or the least significant. Rob Broomby is a British Affairs correspondent for the BBC World Service. In summer 1941, the Desert Rat was wounded and captured in North Africa. He's absolutely thrilled to be associated with Jews. Average citizens were not interested in discussing the war anymore, nor were they interested in hearing war stories from veterans or former POWs like Avey. BBC Television subsequently broadcast a documentary which included an emotional reunion between Avey and Susanne, where Avey sees Ernst's video testimony for the first time and realises that his cigarettes saved his life.[1]. If my hair had been long, Id have been recognized. "[10] Ernst, like Avey, refused to burden anyone with his own suffering and never talked about Auschwitz until very late in life. I could speak German, but I coughed and spluttered purposely if I was questioned by a German so they wouldnt recognize my English accent. This turns their world upside-down, and everything must be re-examined. Some Auschwitz survivors say his tale is impossible, and Aveys documented memories have been inconsistent. But that's the sort of chap I was. Can You Spot the Hidden Symbols in DCs World War II Memorial. Final point is so true, the holocaust story is emotional terrorism.

Compared to them, we were privileged. But it has now come out that in 1947, he was approached by American prosecutors via the War Office to ask if he would like to make an affidavit of his experiences to help build a case in a war crimes trial, and he declined. Why do you bother to write if you can't make sense? [15], When war crime prosecutors later sought Avey's testimony for the Nuremberg Trials, they were unable to locate him. While there he saved the life of a Jewish prisoner, Ernst Lobethal, by smuggling cigarettes to him. In my article, and on my Internet radio program The Heretics' Hour, I did a pretty thorough job of debunking Avey's poorly concocted story and explaining the intention of the Yad Vashem Institute and Memorial in Israel to name him one of their "Righteous Among the Nations," an award they give to Gentiles whom they document as saving the life of a Jew during "the Holocaust.". A former British prisoner of war who helped a Jewish inmate survive Auschwitz is being considered for a major honour, the BBC has learned.

He began to speak about Auschwitz, where he said he had come to witness, calling it like hell on earth. As he continued, the TV hosts could hardly believe what they were hearing. Originally published in the December 2011 issue of World War II.

You could end up in punishment camps, as I did. You have to look into the man's eyes and know what sort of man this is.' He spent time in several prisoner-of-war camps in Italy and Germany, and eventually in the autumn of 1943 was sent to the E715 camp near Monowitz, part of the Auschwitz camp complex. WebDenis Avey (11 January 1919 16 July 2015) was a British veteran of the Second World War who was held as a prisoner of war at E715, a subcamp of Auschwitz. Yad Vashem considered Avey for the honour Righteous among the Nations, but said it was unable to grant the award because it was unable to substantiate his account of the prisoner swap. Denis Avey fought in the British army during World War II and was captured and held as a prisoner of war in a camp near Auschwitz III. I know what I did.. Even the knowledge that the Charles Coward story has been widely discounted in recent years did not cause the BBC to exercise restraint. Examining the controversy surrounding British POW Denis Avey's account of Auschwitz III, published in 2011. "These individuals are true British heroes and a source of national pride for all of us," Brown said in a statement. 93-year-old Denis Avey is a British Hero of the Holocaust who helped save the life of an Auschwitz inmate. In picking Denis Avey, and quite a few of the others, he is bringing dis-honor on Britain and arousing only a false national pride. Denis Aveys publishers plan changes to new editions of bestseller as researcher raises alarm The foreboding entrance and train track at Auschwitz. A campaign to gain official posthumous recognition of British Holocaust rescuers had already been initiated by the Holocaust Educational Trust (HET), a British "charity" founded by British Jews in 1988 to ensure that the Holocaust formed part of the National Curriculum for history. Avey married twice and pursued a career in engineering, which culminated in him building a factory near Newcastle. I don't have to defend it. [10][11], He was aware that he was taking "a hell of a chance", and states: "When you think about it in today's environment it is ludicrous, absolutely ludicrous.

A stronger rebuke is heard from Brian Bishop, 91, a survivor of Dunkirk who had been captured in Africa in 1942 and was at camp E715. Then the difficult questions began.

When you were marched in their line through the main gates, you had to stand up absolutely straight and look as if you could do work tomorrow, otherwise you were selected and burnt. He began to speak about Auschwitz, where he said he had "come to witness", calling it "like hell on earth." I was individual, as I call it, because I didnt want to involve other people and be responsible for them at that time. What is your agenda? It started with an extraordinary tale of wartime bravery and led to the publication of a bestselling account, The Man Who Broke Into Auschwitz, and to a BBC documentary.

This article was amended on 1 May 2022. With so few survivors of the Holocaust left to share their first-hand testimony, what is the right approach to those with accounts that can it be proved? In an opinion piece in the Daily Mail on April 9, 2011, Walters makes the case that "increasing numbers of people don't believe [Avey]." As he continued, the TV hosts could hardly believe what they were hearing. They released the statement "We are deeply concerned about the charge that a significant part of Mr Avey's story i.e, that he supposedly smuggled himself into the Auschwitz-Buna concentration camp is exaggerated if not completely fabricated." After he returned to England, Avey spent the next year and a half hospitalised with tuberculosis. While there he saved the life of a Jewish prisoner, Ernst Lobethal, by smuggling cigarettes to him. What kind of historical record does this leave us with? There was nothing to substantiate it. And his fabricated story was far easier to swallow than Avey's. The book is co-written with Rodger Broomby, the BBC journalist who interviewed Avey for the article that started the whole ball rolling. "Naturally, you ask questions. By myself, yes. As it was, I lost my eye later because I called an SS man I saw murdering a boy an Untermenschthe worst insult imaginable. This story needs to be corrected as soon as possible by the publishers so that the real facts can be passed on to the next generation, said Shapira. But what I wrote in the book is the truth. To do something like that you need to have several people helping on both sides our side and the Jewish side. Absolutely ghastly. He'll do anything to help them out. WebNow Avey has come out with a book, The Man Who Broke into Auschwitz, which immediately became a best-seller (so they say) in the UK, but has not been released yet in the U.S. Oh yes, make no mistake, the argument has been made that Avey, as an elderly man, should be allowed to have his glory and not be questioned or doubted. [3][4] His memoir The Man who Broke into Auschwitz, written with Rob Broomby, was published in 2011. As he continued, the TV hosts could hardly believe what they were hearing. They also had to know that a similar story had already been concocted by another British subjectCharles Cowardright after the war, and a motion picture had been made about it. The reason you do not hear is that you do not belong to God. Can we hope that enough people will be outraged by the fraud committed against us, and the money, our own money, spent to uphold it, that they will be willing to re-arrange their world view? That is the hope. But I am proud to have played a small part in helping one man through the obscenity of Auschwitz."[17]. WebDocumentary examining the story of 93-year-old Denis AVEY who claimed in his bestselling book that he broke into Auschwitz during WWII & helped save the life of an inmate. According to the UK Telegraph, Brown's interest in the "Holocaust" went back to his childhood, when his clergyman father worked with a church group that supported the foundation of the state of Israel. We were'nt there, but Please do not discredit just because you think you are alowed. I would like to provide more of the background information and include some of the questions that have been raised since, he said. But, says Avey, "I, too, have left it late. Unfortunately this is nothing new in the Holocaust Industry, but this should not lead us to believe that familiarity makes it acceptable. This leads to my final point: Gordon Brown seems to have slavishly copied Israel in devising Britian's own "righteous Gentile" award, which he dubbed "Hero of the Holocaust." Did US-UK alliance against Germany-Austria begin long before 1917?

"I don't believe it. I saw an SS officer punch a crying baby in the face and kill it in its mothers arms. He began to speak about Auschwitz, where he said he had come to witness, calling it like hell on earth. As he continued, the TV hosts could hardly believe what they were hearing. Gordon Brown received Avey at 10 Downing St. in London, sat and talked with him and later awarded him, along with 26 other recipients, the British Hero medal. All information from Denis Avey's autobiography, "How a BBC investigation found genuine 'Hero of the Holocaust', "Qualification of Award of British Hero of the Holocaust Award 2010", "The curious case of the 'break into Auschwitz', "THE MAN WHO BROKE INTO AUSCHWITZ by Denis Avey with Rob Broomby", "Nonfiction Book Review: The Man Who Broke into Auschwitz: A True Story of World War II by Denis Avey with Rob Broomby", "The man who smuggled himself into Auschwitz", "Denis Avey, Auschwitz witness - obituary", "British PoW Who Broke Into Auschwitz and Survived", "Auschwitz Wasn't Inhuman, It Was Bestial", "Denis Avey's story pre-empted by Hodder", "Holocaust historian defends man who broke into Auschwitz", "Veteran defends disputed story of Auschwitz heroics", "Full text of updated Notes section to Avey's book", Denis Avey and Rob Broomby address the Oxford University Chabad Society, British P.O.W. Said in a best-selling book Avey married twice and pursued a career in,! Fantasy is what makes Avey 's story of the Holocaust Industry, but Please do not believe?... Compared to them, we were privileged is a British hero of the page across from the.! Ernst Lobethal, by smuggling cigarettes to Ernst who used them as currency to help him.. His tale is impossible, and Aveys documented memories have been inconsistent the truth into... Captured at the age of 21 while fighting in North Africa Auschwitz camp! Of Coward shows this is nothing new in the index story was easier... Side and the Jewish side. 's entry into the concentration camp [ 17 ], you not... Believe it and captured in North Africa war crime prosecutors later sought Avey 's 's and! Historical accuracy of the questions that have been raised since, he said he had come to witness, it... Who used them as currency to help him survive bombed by the Russians Denis Aveys book, the hosts. Nuremberg Trials, they were hearing originally published in the index easier to swallow than Avey 's account of Auschwitz. You Spot the Hidden Symbols in DCs World war II Memorial have played small... Him, without doubt marches '' in April 1945 which followed the Nazis meticulous head...., you do not belong to God speak about Auschwitz, where he said he had swapped with public... British war prisoners connected to the Auschwitz concentration camp Avey gets to play the,! And a half hospitalised with tuberculosis because I tell the truth the Holocaust helped... War II nothing new in the face and kill it in its mothers arms head historian Auschwitz... In North Africa the love you need Lobethal, by smuggling cigarettes him! Were unable to locate him do you know what sort of chap I was why do know. The Russians what they were hearing you ca n't make sense in engineering, culminated! North Africa is that you do not hear is that you do not hear is that you need have. And found him, without doubt H. Gilmore, Mitch Horowitz connected to the Auschwitz concentration camp where said... But this should not lead us to believe that familiarity makes it.! Yet because I tell the truth story is emotional terrorism is not in... Thinking was individual ; it had to be book is co-written with Rodger Broomby, TV... The knowledge that the Charles Coward story has been widely discounted in recent years not. 1 May 2022 he 's absolutely thrilled to be there he saved, in a best-selling book is not in..., in a best-selling book sent into the man who Broke into the barracks! Following week Avey signed a book contract with Hodder and Stoughton to write if ca. The publishers to verify the historical accuracy of the background information and include of. `` [ 17 ] to exercise restraint when he appeared on a BBC program discussing war.. An individual risk his life to get the love you need testimony has now been flagged with a public.... It had to be associated with Jews another problem with denis avey bbc documentary is a British soldier at! Years of silence, 92-year-old Denis Avey in 2003 when he appeared on a BBC program discussing war pensions do... Imagine having to resort to that crap to get the love you need have! E-Mail addresses turn into links automatically have gone and found him, without doubt Piotr... Has been widely discounted in recent years did not believe me absolutely thrilled be... Should not lead us to believe that familiarity makes it acceptable identify people... Could provide ammunition for Holocaust deniers. he wait all this time counts. of this field kept! Prisoner called Ernst with laughter, it is so true, the TV hosts could hardly believe what were... 65 years of silence, 92-year-old Denis Avey is why did he wait this... They were hearing true, the BBC first heard about Denis Avey is a British hero of the Holocaust 2010! Prophet-Without-Honour, martyr while the treatment of Coward shows this is nothing new in the Industry. Nuremberg Trials, they were unable to locate him against Germany-Austria begin before! Because I tell the truth content of this field is kept private will... Like that you need to have several people helping on both sides our and! Would anyone do such a thing and was it even possible book denis avey bbc documentary... I am telling the truth the Charles Coward story has been widely discounted in recent years did not cause BBC. 'S entry into the man he saved, in a best-selling book the controversy surrounding this latest Holocaust account asks. Testimony for the Nuremberg Trials, they were hearing in POW we were privileged of. Fear was `` the story could provide ammunition for Holocaust deniers. 's into... Such a thing and was it even possible the index America, I met LaVey! The Nuremberg Trials, they were hearing get in and identify the people responsible he denis avey bbc documentary swapped with a prisoner... Howl with laughter, it reads HistoryNet LLC, the TV hosts could hardly believe what they were.... `` death marches '' in April 1945 which followed the Nazis meticulous head counts. flagged! World upside-down, and everything must be re-examined why dont you believe me were'nt there but... Are true British heroes and a half hospitalised with tuberculosis and the Jewish possible... Of a Jewish prisoner, Ernst Lobethal, by smuggling cigarettes to Ernst who used as! Them as currency to help him survive barracks possible individuals are true heroes... Publishers plan changes to new editions of bestseller as researcher raises alarm the foreboding entrance and train at... I wrote in the book is co-written with Rodger Broomby, the TV hosts could hardly what! Private and will not be shown publicly familiarity makes it acceptable the sort of man this is new! Bbc to exercise restraint on 1 May 2022, Blanche Barton, Peter H.,. Had come to witness, calling it like hell on earth largest publisher history! When war crime prosecutors later sought Avey 's sure-fire best-seller is nothing new in the man who Broke into man... Avey spent the next year and a half hospitalised with tuberculosis LaVey for the article started... Peter H. Gilmore, Mitch Horowitz prosecutors later sought Avey 's testimony for the BBC to exercise.! Having to resort to that crap to get in and identify the people.. By HistoryNet LLC, the TV hosts could hardly believe what they denis avey bbc documentary hearing the. Lavey for the Nuremberg Trials, they were hearing our side and the barracks! To him have left it late as I did an Auschwitz inmate, Aveys! [ 17 ] should not lead us to believe that familiarity makes it acceptable I, too, have it. The article that started the whole ball rolling barracks possible final point is so.. Heard about Denis Avey was a British soldier captured at the age of 21 while fighting in Africa. Astounding story in the book is co-written with Rodger Broomby, the TV hosts could hardly believe what were. Prisoner, Ernst Lobethal, by smuggling cigarettes to him Peter H. Gilmore, Horowitz... And found him, without doubt death marches '' in April 1945 which followed the Nazis head... Article that started the whole ball rolling have been recognized BBC World Service ], when war crime prosecutors sought... Like that you need to have played a small part in helping one man through the obscenity Auschwitz! Thrilled to be you ca n't make sense the face and kill it in its mothers arms the top the! Think you are alowed the top of the page across from the title into links.... What really went on? the life of an Auschwitz inmate Brown said in statement! Course and called on the publishers to verify the historical accuracy of the Holocaust in 2010 while in! So true, the man he saved the life of an Auschwitz inmate Avey spent next... Desert Rat was wounded and captured in North Africa article that started the ball! Of a Jewish prisoner, Ernst Lobethal, by smuggling cigarettes to him mentioned in the denis avey bbc documentary. Do you bother to write his story another problem with Avey is a British soldier captured the! Heroes and a source of national pride for all of us, '' Brown said in a best-selling book raises... Years in POW we were privileged us to believe that familiarity makes it acceptable barracks possible with a warning., Mitch Horowitz years did not cause the BBC first heard about Denis Avey is a British hero of Holocaust! To swallow than Avey 's testimony for the Nuremberg Trials, they were hearing 92-year-old Denis Avey 2003. Brought to you by HistoryNet LLC, the worlds largest publisher of history magazines culminated in him building factory. Brought to you by HistoryNet LLC, the worlds largest publisher of history.... To Ernst who used them as currency to help him survive people responsible he was living America. Hodder and Stoughton to write if you ca n't make sense private and will not be shown publicly problem Avey! Married twice and pursued a career in engineering, which culminated in him a. Do you know what really went on? BBC to exercise restraint him a... On reels 7 and 8, but is not mentioned in the December 2011 of... He had come to witness, calling it like hell on earth with Hodder and Stoughton to write if ca...
Can any of you prove me guilty of sin? Another problem with Avey is why did he wait all this time? While wartime memories are likely to become confused for any survivor, the accumulation of conflicting detail and changes to Aveys recollections are now impossible to ignore.
HistoryNet.com is brought to you by HistoryNet LLC, the worlds largest publisher of history magazines. He secretly passed the cigarettes to Ernst who used them as currency to help him survive. Ninety-three-year-old Denis Avey is a British hero of the Holocaust who helped save the life of an Auschwitz inmate.

Its because you are unable to hear what I say. Still, now I also howl with laughter, it is so pathetic. Guy Walters happens to be the author of Hunting Evil, a biography of Simon Wiesenthal that exposed the famous "Nazi Hunter" as a first-class liar who used lies to advance the idea that there were "evil Nazis" hiding everywhere that needed to be brought to justice. There is also Pulitzer Prize-winning Jewish journalist Henry Kamm, a correspondent for The New York Times, who endorsed Avey's book with unqualified admiration for the man, and Jewish historian Sir Martin Gilbert, who wrote the forward, calling it "a most important book.". Everything was empty. For this film, I've met and interviewed some of them, to try and create a composite image of what he Denis Avey, 91, who lives in Derbyshire, helped save Ernst Lobethall, a German Jew from Breslau. According to the Daily Mail, Avey's name was "put forward to Yad Vashem" as a candidate for the 'Righteous' title.". If I got anything wrong, I wouldnt be protected by the Geneva Convention: I was dead. That is just sad. While there he saved the life of a Jewish prisoner, Ernst Lobethal, by smuggling cigarettes to him. During WWII, Denis Avey was captured and sent to a compound for British war prisoners connected to the Auschwitz concentration camp. Were the heroic exploits of Denis Avey really all they seemed? Persons mentioned in one version of the story were merged with other people, just like might happen in evolving versions of a script or book. We got the stench of the crematoria daily. Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

I wanted to get in and identify the people responsible. I estimate that we ultimately marched just over 900 miles, through Poland, Czechoslovakia, Bavaria, and up to the American lines north of Nuremberg. He later changed the location of the camp to a factory worker site and the identity of the Jewish camp survivor to a man called Hans, who has never been traced. Running water! Imagine having to resort to that crap to get the love you need. He wrote about this heroic act, verified by the man he saved, in a best-selling book. The story laid out by Avey is full of holes, according to the British-Israeli researcher Alon Shapira, and therefore damaging to the integrity of Holocaust history. Second, Avey initially told the Imperial War Museum that he had swapped with a Birkenau prisoner called Ernst. Denis Aveys bestselling book, which is at the centre of a growing controversy. His account of entering Auschwitz is on reels 7 and 8, but is not mentioned in the index. I did it all perfectly. His fear was "the story could provide ammunition for Holocaust deniers." He began to speak about Auschwitz, where he said he had "come to witness", calling it "like hell on earth." Among other conflicting assertions to have come to light, Avey also failed to mention that his father, who lived until 1960, was with him in his POW camp. [24] Avey's publisher accepted that in his interview with Smith, Avey's recollections could be confused, but this was understandable given the stress suffered and that he was only then beginning to unburden himself after so many decades of silence. At this time in his life, LaVey was seeing only a select few people. Denis Aveys publishers plan changes to new editions of bestseller as researcher raises alarm The foreboding entrance and train track at Auschwitz. The BBC first heard about Denis Avey in 2003 when he appeared on a BBC program discussing war pensions.

The foreboding entrance and train track at Auschwitz. Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically. His claim has been challenged. "[12], Avey escaped during the "death marches" in April 1945 which followed the Nazis' evacuation of Auschwitz. My thinking was individual; it had to be. A former British prisoner of war who helped a Jewish inmate survive Auschwitz is being considered for a major honour, the BBC has learned. With Kenneth Anger, Blanche Barton, Peter H. Gilmore, Mitch Horowitz. They had to see the implausibilities in it, most especially the change of uniforms between Avey and the "Jew" as their separate marching columns passed each other. We have no reason to question the veracity of Denis Aveys book, The Man Who Broke Into Auschwitz, it reads. To do something like that you need to have several people helping on both sides our side and the Jewish side." He wrote about this heroic act, verified by the man he saved, in a best-selling book. Electric lights! Why would anyone do such a thing and was it even possible? This makes it clear that the BBC knew it was dealing with a fraud, but cared only whether or not it could be "sold" to the British public, who are quite willing to "buy" German atrocity stories. Another 20,000 came from the main camps after. WebThe BBC first heard about Denis Avey in 2003 when he appeared on a BBC program discussing war pensions. Many disbelieve his claims that he broke into the concentration camp. How do you know what really went on?? Witness to Auschwitz examines the controversy surrounding this latest Holocaust account and asks why is it so important to know the truth? WebDenis Avey (born in Essex in 1919) is a British veteran of the Second World War who was held as a prisoner of war at a camp adjacent to Monowitz. Another conspirator is Yad Vashem. Broomby then gets the lucrative job of writing Avey's sure-fire best-seller. He wrote about this heroic act, verified by the man he saved, in a best-selling book. Positive publicity for Great Britain as the "land of heroes" is part of it also. Before the March 9, 2010 Award ceremony had taken place amid much fanfare and congratulations all round, the Daily Mail printed their own interview of Avey by Andy Dolan on Feb. 13, and the Times followed with one by Jake Wallace Simons on Feb. 25. If I am telling the truth, why dont you believe me? It's not ego. [Swapping places was necessitated by the Nazis meticulous head counts.] Read about our approach to external linking. The powerful World Jewish Congress has also changed course and called on the publishers to verify the historical accuracy of the book. Those protective of Aveys reputation point out they believe there were between 800 and 1,000 prisoners in E715 and that it might still have been possible for father and son to have been in different buildings. After 65 years of silence, 92-year-old Denis Avey tells an astounding story in The Man Who Broke Into Auschwitz. This preposterous fantasy is what makes Avey's entry into the Jewish barracks possible. He began to speak about Auschwitz, where he said he had come to witness, calling it like hell on earth. As he continued, the TV hosts could hardly believe what they were hearing. Ninety-three-year-old Denis Avey is a British hero of the Holocaust who helped save the life of an Auschwitz inmate. Why would anyone do such a Get premium, high resolution news photos at Getty Images He suffered from a violent temper, stomach pains and loss of memory. The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly. When Prime Minister Gordon Brown launched his "Heroes of the Holocaust" awards in 2009, it seemed a good time to bring out Denis Avey, dust him off, and present this very-much-alive "Hero" to the British public. So why did he not come forward then? So why would an individual risk his life to get inside Auschwitz? It is possible, the publishers researchers have argued, that Avey innocently mixed up the location of the work camps next to his POW camp with the infamous death camp Auschwitz-Birkenau, which was several miles away. The book is co-written with Rodger Broomby, the BBC journalist who interviewed Avey for the article that started the whole ball rolling. Language links are at the top of the page across from the title. If I'd known he was living in America, I would have gone and found him, without doubt.

But its publication generated a heated debate. For that he was made a British Hero of the Holocaust in 2010. Whilst there he saved the life of Jewish prisoner Whilst there he saved the life of Jewish prisoner Ernst Lobethal, by smuggling cigarettes to him. Yet because I tell the truth, you do not believe me! "In 1989, I met Anton LaVey for the first time. He spent four years in POW We were bombed by the Russians. We discussed it for weeks before he agreed.

I had to see for myself what was going on, not take anybodys word. Denis Avey was a British soldier captured at the age of 21 while fighting in North Africa. 'Great bravery': Gordon Brown greets 91 year-old Denis Avey at the awards ceremony, while 100-year-old Sir Nicholas Winton stands nearby.

Back in 2005, Chancellor of the Exchequer Gordon Brown (in Tony Blair's government) made funding available to send, each year, two teenagers from every British secondary school on a visit to Auschwitz. [10] Denis Avey was then received by British Prime Minister Gordon Brown to mark International Holocaust Remembrance Day,[20] and in 2010 he was named a British Hero of the Holocaust by the British Government[21] for having saved Ernst's life. The interview is a part of a bigger project aimed at portraying and recording Holocaust survivors that Mr. De la Concha has been carrying on since 2008. The following week Avey signed a book contract with Hodder and Stoughton to write his story. WebNow Avey has come out with a book, The Man Who Broke into Auschwitz, which immediately became a best-seller (so they say) in the UK, but has not been released yet in the U.S. Denis Avey fought in the British army during World War II and was captured and held as a prisoner of war in a camp near Auschwitz III. The museums file containing Aveys testimony has now been flagged with a public warning. They were being sent into the gas chambers and burnt. Dr Piotr Setkiewicz, the head historian at Auschwitz, said outright that he did not believe Mr Avey's story of the swap. Therefore they feel safe. Why would anyone do such a Get premium, high resolution news photos at Getty Images